Return to site

PXI vs. MXI Controllers

· test,test system,PXI

I'm working on another proposal and the system will have a PXI system that will go into a rack. I'm going to present two options for a controller: PXI or MXI.

I'm going to recommend a PXI controller as I think there's general price insensitivity here (the controller is a small part of the cost). In general though I like the small size. If I need a full size desktop PC along with my PXI chassis, then I'm likely using over 10U in my rack. (This doesn't count other things like a keyboard tray, maybe a rackmount surge protector or UPS.) My preference is to keep test systems as small (and as mobile) as possible which will increase flexibility. I'd rather not require a full size rack unless I really do have a lot instrumentation.

I think one undervalued aspect of PXI controllers is that their product lifetime is higher than a standard PC. For instance, I can buy a PXI-8101 controller, which was released in 2009. This comes in handy in regulated environments where duplicating a system means duplicating everything exactly. If I want to still use a Celeron processor, I can (though the PXI-8101 specifically is in last time buy.)

But maybe you don't want your system tied to yesterday's processor. Having a separate PC with MXI is a much better choice. You can update the PC or any of its components without touching the PXI chassis. It is also much cheaper. For example, the PXIe-8840 controller is $4599 for a dual core and $5599 for a quad core. The PXIe-PCIe8361 controller is $1199. Estimating a PC at $1000 means that the MXI option is roughly half price.

One other advantage for the standard PC route is that PCI/PCIe peripherals are much cheaper than PXI. And while in most cases there are equivalent USB peripherals, it's nice to have them in your PC. For instance, if I need a few extra Serial ports, USB ports, and/or Ethernet ports, PCI is a much more cost effective choice.

So we'll have to see which option is preferred (or if the system is build at all.)

Disclosure: I own shares of National Instruments stock.

All Posts

Almost done…

We just sent you an email. Please click the link in the email to confirm your subscription!

OKSubscriptions powered by Strikingly